Creepy Creatures Introduce
In the world of pet ownership, there are those who seek the traditional companionship of a dog or cat, and then there are those who are captivated by the unique and fascinating world of exotic animals. For New Yorkers with a passion for reptiles, arachnids, amphibians, and other "creepy creatures," finding a dedicated and knowledgeable store is a true game-changer. Located in the heart of Farmingdale, Long Island, Creepy Creatures has established itself as a go-to destination for enthusiasts of all ages. This store is more than just a retail space; it's a vibrant hub where experts and newcomers alike can share their passion, learn about new species, and find everything they need to properly care for their extraordinary pets. This article will provide a comprehensive overview of what makes Creepy Creatures a special place, from its welcoming atmosphere and expert staff to its unique offerings and community-focused approach.
Creepy Creatures stands out by focusing on a niche that is often overlooked by large-scale pet chains. They are a small business with a big heart, a fact that is immediately apparent from the genuine care and enthusiasm of their team. As real customer reviews attest, the staff's patience, kindness, and deep knowledge are what truly define the experience. Whether you're a seasoned herpetologist or a curious parent with a five-year-old, the employees take the time to answer questions, share their expertise, and even allow visitors to get hands-on experience with some of the animals. This creates a fun and educational environment that encourages responsible pet ownership and fosters a love for these misunderstood animals. The store’s unique and playful decor adds to the charm, making it a destination for a family outing as much as it is a place to shop. The positive and informative interactions, as highlighted in customer testimonials, showcase the store’s commitment to building a community around the shared love of exotic pets.
For those in New York, the ability to find a specialized store with expert advice is invaluable. Creepy Creatures fills this gap perfectly, offering a sanctuary for enthusiasts and a place for the curious to explore. This guide will take you through the details of the store, from its convenient location in Farmingdale to the specific services and features that make it a standout choice for anyone looking to add a little 'creepiness' to their life.
Creepy Creatures is located at 704 Main St in Farmingdale, NY 11735. This spot on Long Island makes it easily accessible for residents of Nassau and Suffolk counties, as well as those willing to travel from other parts of the city for a specialized experience. The store’s location on Main Street places it within a lively downtown area, making it a convenient stop for a quick visit. The business offers key accessibility features, including a wheelchair-accessible entrance and a wheelchair-accessible parking lot, which ensures a welcoming and accommodating experience for all customers.
The store is well-suited for a "quick visit," as noted in its business information, which is a significant plus for busy New Yorkers. The availability of on-site parking adds to this convenience, eliminating the stress of finding a spot in a busy commercial area. For those who prefer to browse and take their time, the central location on Main Street allows for a leisurely stroll before or after a visit to the store, and its unique, fun decor makes the interior a destination in itself.
Creepy Creatures provides a focused range of services tailored to the specific needs of exotic pet owners.
Expert Consultation: The staff, including specialists like Tom and April mentioned in reviews, are highly knowledgeable about a wide range of exotic animals. They take the time to answer questions and provide detailed explanations on everything from animal behavior to proper husbandry.
In-Store Pickup: For customers who prefer to order ahead, the store offers a convenient in-store pickup service. This allows for a quick and efficient transaction, perfect for replenishing supplies or picking up a pre-selected pet.
"Lizard-Sitting" and Boarding Services: As highlighted in customer reviews, the store provides care services like "lizard-sitting," which is a unique and invaluable service for exotic pet owners needing to travel or go on vacation. It demonstrates their commitment to the long-term well-being of the animals they sell.
Educational Experiences: The employees are happy to talk and teach customers, including children, about the different animals. This creates an engaging and educational environment that goes beyond a typical retail experience.
Several features make Creepy Creatures a unique and highly recommended destination for exotic pet enthusiasts in New York.
Specialized Inventory: The store specializes in reptiles, arachnids, and other exotic creatures, offering a curated selection of animals like tarantulas and lizards. This focus ensures that they have a deep understanding of their specific niche and the supplies needed to care for these animals.
Passionate and Patient Staff: The team at Creepy Creatures is consistently praised for their passion, patience, and kindness, especially with new pet owners and children. Their willingness to educate customers and their genuine love for the animals set them apart.
Kid-Friendly Atmosphere: The store is noted for being "very kid friendly," with an atmosphere that encourages young visitors to learn and interact with the animals. The fun decor and patient staff make it a great family destination.
Personalized Support: The store offers ongoing support, encouraging customers to reach out with questions at any time. This commitment to post-purchase care builds trust and loyalty, making customers feel supported in their new pet journey.
For all inquiries or to learn more about their products and services, you can contact Creepy Creatures using the following information:
Address: 704 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA
Phone: (516) 586-4080
Choosing Creepy Creatures is a decision to embark on a unique and rewarding pet ownership journey with a knowledgeable and friendly partner. This small business offers a level of expertise and personalized service that is simply not available at larger, more generalized pet stores. The staff's genuine passion for exotic animals, combined with their patience and willingness to educate, provides an unparalleled experience for customers of all ages and experience levels. The store’s specialization in reptiles and arachnids means you can be confident in the health and quality of the animals and supplies you purchase. For New Yorkers looking to add a lizard, tarantula, or other extraordinary creature to their family, Creepy Creatures offers a fun, safe, and supportive environment. Its unique services, like "lizard-sitting," and its commitment to ongoing customer support make it an invaluable resource. In a city where it can be hard to find a store with a niche focus and a personal touch, Creepy Creatures truly stands out as the ideal choice for all things extraordinary.
Creepy Creatures Details
From the business
- Small business
Service options
- In-store pickup
- Delivery
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Creepy Creatures Photos










Creepy Creatures Location
Creepy Creatures Reviews
questionspriceslizardstarantulasinformationownerknowledgeneedstree frogcrested gecko
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Before I even walked in i called and spoke to Tom on the phone and he answered all my questions and took the time to explain everything I was asking. Then when I went in let me tell you how awesome every person was!!! This is now my goto store for my tarantulas and lizards!!! Everyone there is amazing truly no words can describe!!!! Thank you for everything!!!!!
July 15 · Christopher WilkieWe found Creepy Creatures on a random Google search and we liked the name so we decided to visit and window shop. The next thing we knew knew , Pumpkin was coming home with us ! Our new friend April was feeding all of the animals when we came in with my 5 year old. She was so patient , kind and fun! She taught us all kinds of things and even let Rebecca watch her and help her. April, Joe and all of the other employees were super nice and patient as we invaded their space , Rebecca watching everything they were doing . Very kid friendly ! The decor around the shop is so much fun, the employees are patient and happy to talk and teach , and of course there are a ton of creepy creatures to choose from! They even have lizard-sitting services and told us to reach out any time with questions. I highly recommend Creepy Creatures for the next time you’re looking to “window shop” for a new family member ◡̈
June 27 · Rachel LeyaGreat service from Tom Joe and Gary, great people and vary informational when it came to buying my first snake and starter kit
August 17 · B HThe most knowledgeable reptile store I have ever been to. I bought a baby crested gecko and they helped me set up a bioactive tank. You can tell that the staff really love reptiles from how nicely the reptiles are cared for in the store. If you are looking to become a new reptile owner or if you are planning on buying more reptiles, I would recommend coming to this store. The prices are also very reasonable and not expensive compared to other stores. 10/10 experience!!
May 25 · Ivana JovanovskiGot a stunning, well priced ball python there. Learned a lot from the owner.
August 28 · Zachary Binder
More Pet Store Near Me

5500 Sunrise Hwy, Massapequa, NY 11758, USA

61 Sunrise Hwy, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, USA

1141 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA

127 W Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, USA

750 Montauk Hwy, Copiague, NY 11726, USA

548 Sunrise Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA

185 Great East Neck Rd, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA

655 Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA

2435 Grand Ave, Bellmore, NY 11710, USA

26 Silver Birch Rd, Merrick, NY 11566, USA

2112 Deer Park Ave, Deer Park, NY 11729, USA

141 John St # 600, Babylon, NY 11702, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Pet & Vet Blogs Posts





